The report claiming that the music written by the petitioner is unprofessional and of low-quality is not true.
2016 Seoul Arbitration 987?988
Requests for Correction of a news report and Compensation for injury
Bae OO
Kyunghyang Shinmun
Seoul Arbitral Tribunal 3
2016. 07. 06.
Settlement by mediation (correction of the news report)
Internet Kyunghyang Shinmun - A news article titled Nasty Fake Songs - Waste of money, not Pleasant to Ears ( Entertainment section dated on June 16, 2016 )
A, an office worker, recently experienced something absurd. He/she searched “Frozen” from his favorite online music download store for his/her child. Then he/she mindlessly clicked on the song that appeared on the top of the search result list. However, despite his/her expectation, what was played was lounge music. He/she took a second look and realized that the song he selected had no relevance to the original soundtrack of the movie Frozen. The album jacket was different and the artist’s name was Punch Punch. The album contained three pieces of music called “Frozen Winter”, “Frozen Piano” and “Frozen Beat”, all of which were placed even higher on the download chart than the original sound track. All of the three songs were so sloppy and simple that they would be good for sample songs that are pre-recorded in electronic instruments.
There are more cases that are similar to what A experienced. If you search Byul gudae (an abbreviation of Byulaeseo on gudae, which is a TV series
B. You would click on the song expecting Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata. However, four measures of the first movement of the Moonlight Sonata would be repeated then the music would get mixed with other lounge music, as if the song is a joke. This is a fake music that borrowed the title of the famous music piece, the Moonlight Sonata. Many of such songs are distributed recently at major online music download stores. This is so called “music abusing” in a sense that unprofessional and low-quality music is continuously released with the same title as that of popular music or famous media content. As a result, these bogus songs top the chart when consumers search for a specific song. This phenomenon, which the music industry started to see two or three years ago, has recently been on the rise. The reason behind this abusing is that this method can earn easy profits. Once a user clicks on a song, fee is incurred for the music. The fee per song is not much, however, music industry insiders point out that some music providers employ a mass distribution strategy and provide numerous songs to make some millions of won of profit per month. These distributors come up with new clickbaits so that music consumers would click on the songs even by accident. Other than the fake songs mentioned above, one can find many clickbait songs that stole titles of famous movies such as Miss Granny, Begin Again, or The Avengers.
C, the head of the Bugs Music group, said, “Quite a large number of music providers intentionally release hundreds of songs a day online, however online music retailers cannot distinguish or filter out all of such fake music, song by song. As a result, the accumulated garbage songs are causing trouble for consumers.” “Increasing number of music providers are out for a chance for their songs to be clicked on when the users search songs. Sometimes original songs lose out to the fake songs on keyword search charts,” he explained. “The music industry shares a black list of such distributors but more and more clickbait songs are released online. Those songs may be awful to listen to, but they also are a kind of creative work and do not infringe on copyrights. So it is almost impossible to find ways to regulate them,” he added. The genres where many clickbait songs are created are new age, children’s song, Korean traditional music and classical music. Relatively fewer consumers listen to music in these genres, thus it is easier for fake songs to make it to the top of the search chart; “music abusing” works much better in these genres.
D, the secretary general of Korea Music Content Industry Association, emphasized, “An effective way to reduce consumer damages is to check artist’s name, title or design of the album jacket of the song you find on the top of the keyword search charts before clicking on it without thinking.”
Report
The respondent, in its news report on the bankruptcy of a travel agency in Gangnam area, called the travel agency in question “Gangnam travel agency.” Other travel agency that has the same name suffered damage from this news report.
2016 Seoul Arbitration 189·190
Requests for Correction of a news report and Compensation for injury
○○ Travel Agency
YTN Corporation
Seoul Arbitral Tribunal 3
2016. 02. 15.
Settlement by mediation (PR and a follow-up report)
YTN - A news report titled Gangnam Travel Agency in Seoul Went Bankrupt - Many Newly Wedded Couples Suffer Damage aired in the program called
Report
The respondent shall publish the news report under Article 1 for 24 hours from 09:00 on March 23, 2016 on the homepage of Internet YTN (http://www.ytn.co.kr). The headline and the body shall be in the same font size as that of the headline and body of usual news articles on the homepage of Internet YTN. The size of the pop-up window shall be 800x600. The headline and body under Article 1 shall also be published at the end of each of the news reports in question.
The petitioner was injured because of the respondent’s misleading depiction of his life in the countryside. Despite his original intention of moving to the countryside, he was depicted as if his only dream is to become a wealthy farmer and as if he is still overly concerned about his children’s education as to utilize online lectures from cities.
2016 Daegu Arbitration 3·4
Requests for Correction of a news report and Compensation for injury
Kim, OO
Kyongbook Ilbo
Daegu Arbitral Tribunal
2016. 01. 12.
Settlement by mediation (reply to the news report)
Kyongbook Ilbo - An article headlined I’ll learn how to grow apple and other specialty produce to be a wealthy farmer (Published in section 15 of the newspaper dated on November 13, 2015)
Report
The petitioner was injured by the respondent’s news report claiming that it was immoral for the petitioner to write an article using an actor’s tweets without having his/her consent.
2015 Seoul Mediation 3438·3439 and 3440
Request for Correction of a news report·Reply
to a news report·Compensation for injury
SocialNews Co., Ltd.
Herald Co., Ltd. (Internet Herald Biz)
Seoul Arbitral Tribunal 8
2015. 08. 27.
Settlement by Mediation (Correction of a news report and Reply to a news report)
Internet Herald Business - A news article titled Actor Kim OO Gets Furious at the Article Written Out of His Comments on Other Actors - What’s Going On? (published in the entertainment and sports section on August 20, 2015)
News Report
By June 29, 2015, the respondent shall;
An editorial cartoon where Claim Adjusters are depicted as involved in insurance frauds for illegal commission is not true.
2015 Seoul Mediation 2971 and 2015 Seoul
Mediation 2972
Request for Correction of a
news report
Korea Insurance Claim Adjusters Association
Korean Bar Association (the KBA News and the Internet KBA News)
Seoul Arbitral Tribunal 4
2015. 06. 02.
Settlement by Mediation (Reply to a news report)
The Korean Bar Association News ㅡ the editorial cartoon titled Uninvited Guests - Uninvted guests, Claim Adjusters (published on the third page of the Korean Bar Association News and in the editorial cartoons section of the Internet Korean Bar Association News on May 11, 2015)
News Report
By June 29, 2015, the respondent shall;
The petitioner's e-cigarette trademark was exposed in a news report covering explosion incidents of low-priced Chinese e-cigarettes, which damaged the petitioner’s business.
2015 Seoul Mediation 2883·2884
Request
for Correction of a news report and
Compensation for injury
OO Korea Co., Ltd. and one person
JTBC Co., Ltd. (JTBC)
Seoul Arbitral Tribunal 3
2015. 05. 07.
Settlement by mediation (Correction of a news report)
JTBC News < Morning& > ㅡ A news report with a headline Low-Priced E-Cigarette Recharge Tests - Cigarettes Exploded In just 8 Minutes (aired in the current issue section on April 23, 2015 )
Anchor | A series of explosions of cheap Chinese e-cigarettes are being reported. Many of the exploded cigarettes were not equipped with safety devices to prevent explosion or ignition, or the safety devices were defective. Jung OO has more. |
---|---|
Reporter | When the female clerk tries to give the customer change back, the e-cigarette that was being charged catches on fire and explodes. |
Reporter | In the U.S., an e-cigarette that is being charged on the table in a factory also explodes all of a sudden. |
Reporter | In Korea, similar incidents happened in Gyeongsan, Gyeongsangbuk-do and Yangpyeong, Gyeonggi-do respectively in January. The exploded e-cigarettes were all low-priced products from China (petiti- oner product’s trademark is exposed). |
A news report script